Loyalty isn’t what it used to be. A recent study by Deloitte found that 50% of consumers are now enrolled in paid loyalty programs, an increase from 32% just two years ago. Yet, this surge in participation hasn’t translated into higher engagement or spending, signalling a massive shift in what customers value.
Points, discounts, and transactional perks that once kept consumers coming back now feel like a bygone era. As personalisation and shared values dominate purchasing decisions, brands tied to outdated loyalty models risk losing not just customers but relevance.
As brands contend with these changing expectations, the question isn’t whether loyalty programs need to evolve but how they can meet the emotional and experiential demands of modern consumers.
The Erosion of Traditional Loyalty Programs
Transactional loyalty programs, once the cornerstone of customer retention, are showing cracks. While these systems thrived in a simpler era of consumer expectations, their appeal is fading in a market driven by emotional resonance and personal connections. The decline of transactional rewards underscores a pressing need for brands to rethink loyalty.
Stagnation in Innovation
The structure of many loyalty programs has remained stagnant for decades. The typical points-for-purchases model fails to differentiate one brand from another.
For consumers juggling multiple loyalty memberships, the experience often feels like an impersonal numbers game rather than a rewarding relationship. A McKinsey report shows that 44% of consumers don’t redeem loyalty points because they find the process too cumbersome or irrelevant.
Shifting Consumer Priorities
Today’s consumers are not just looking for monetary incentives; they want brands to recognise their individuality. Customers are drawn to brands that align with their values, from sustainability to inclusivity. Gen Z, in particular, is leading the charge. According to a recent study, 61% of Gen Z shoppers prefer brands with a clear social impact, suggesting that loyalty is increasingly tied to shared purpose rather than transactional perks.
Generational Divide
Generational shifts are further fueling the erosion of traditional loyalty. While baby boomers may still find comfort in classic points-based programs, millennials and Gen Z prioritise experiences and emotional connections. Younger consumers are more likely to engage with brands that offer exclusive events, behind-the-scenes content, or community-driven initiatives, leaving traditional loyalty programs struggling to maintain relevance.
Emotional and Experiential Loyalty is the New Standard
As traditional loyalty programs falter, brands pivoting to emotional and experiential loyalty are gaining a competitive edge. These strategies go beyond monetary transactions, fostering deeper connections that align with consumers’ evolving expectations.
Building Emotional Connections
The power of storytelling and purpose-driven branding lies at the heart of emotional loyalty. Customers are likelier to stay loyal to brands that resonate with their identity and values. Take Patagonia, for example. The brand has cultivated an intensely loyal community by weaving sustainability into its narrative and actively engaging in environmental activism. Patagonia’s “Worn Wear” initiative, which encourages customers to repair and reuse their products, reinforces its mission and fosters long-term brand loyalty. Customers don’t just buy Patagonia products; they buy into a shared mission to protect the planet.
Experiential Over Transactional
Experiences are now the currency of modern loyalty. Instead of accumulating points, consumers value access to exclusive events, personalised services, and tailored perks. Starbucks Rewards is an example. The program integrates app-based customisation, offering members early access to seasonal drinks and personalised offers based on past purchases. Starbucks also encourages engagement with gamified features, like bonus star challenges, which make customers feel rewarded beyond the purchase. The result? A program that doesn’t just incentivise transactions but builds an emotional connection with coffee enthusiasts.
Community-Driven Loyalty
Consumers crave a sense of belonging. Brands that create spaces for physical or virtual connections see stronger loyalty. Nike’s membership program taps into this by offering exclusive content, fitness challenges, and a sense of camaraderie among its members. This strategy integrates seamlessly with Nike’s ethos of empowerment, turning its customers into a global community of brand advocates. The program’s success lies in its ability to go beyond selling products and cultivate an active lifestyle.
The Future of Loyalty Programs
As consumer expectations continue to evolve, the future of loyalty programs lies in their ability to adapt to emotional, experiential, and technological trends. Brands that harness data, personalisation, and purpose-driven strategies will shape the next era of customer loyalty.
Data-Driven Personalisation
Advances in technology, particularly in artificial intelligence and machine learning, enable brands to tailor loyalty programs to individual preferences. By analyzing purchase history, browsing behaviour, and even social media interactions, brands can offer hyper-personalised rewards that feel meaningful. Sephora’s Beauty Insider program exemplifies this approach, providing product recommendations, birthday gifts, and tiered perks based on members’ spending habits. Personalised experiences ensure customers feel seen and valued, fostering deeper loyalty.
The Role of Content
Content has emerged as a powerful loyalty driver, allowing brands to engage customers beyond transactions. From exclusive tutorials to behind-the-scenes stories, content creates touchpoints that keep customers emotionally invested. Peloton’s immersive fitness content, delivered through its subscription model, has cultivated an intensely loyal user base. By integrating valuable, on-demand content with its product, Peloton transforms loyalty into a holistic experience.
Sustainability and Social Impact
Modern consumers increasingly expect brands to align with their values, particularly around sustainability and social impact. Loyalty programs can serve as platforms to amplify these efforts. For instance, IKEA’s “Buy Back” program rewards customers for returning old furniture, promoting sustainability while building loyalty. Such initiatives demonstrate that loyalty programs can do more than retain customers—they can become a core part of a brand’s identity.
The future of loyalty programs will hinge on their ability to go beyond rewards and embrace strategies that resonate on a deeper, more meaningful level. In the next section, we’ll explore actionable steps brands can take to modernise their approach to loyalty.
Actionable Steps Brands Can Take to Modernise their Approach to Loyalty
- Harness Advanced Personalisation Through AI
Invest in machine learning algorithms to deliver predictive, data-driven personalisation. Tailor loyalty programs are based on real-time customer behaviours, purchase patterns, and even predictive analytics to anticipate needs before they arise. This positions your brand as proactive rather than reactive in meeting customer expectations. - Integrate Experiential Touchpoints
Design loyalty initiatives that go beyond conventional transactions to include immersive experiences. Examples include exclusive previews, behind-the-scenes brand tours, or curated virtual events. These experiences should reflect the brand’s unique value proposition, reinforcing its identity while cultivating emotional resonance. - Build Ecosystems, Not Just Programs
Transform loyalty programs into ecosystems that foster sustained engagement. For example, create an interconnected platform where customers can access rewards, content, and community engagement tools seamlessly. Think beyond “earning points” to a holistic network that rewards every meaningful interaction. - Embed Purpose into Program Design
Purpose-driven loyalty goes beyond a campaign; it should be foundational to your program. Structure rewards around actions that reflect shared values, such as incentivising sustainable practices or creating donation-matching opportunities tied to customer milestones. - Streamline User Experience with Technology
Adopt cutting-edge digital interfaces, such as conversational AI or biometric authentication, to make rewards programs intuitive and frictionless. Prioritise mobile-first designs and integrate loyalty seamlessly into existing customer touchpoints, such as apps or e-commerce platforms. - Emphasise Long-Term Value Creation
Shift focus from short-term customer retention metrics to lifetime value (CLV). Use advanced analytics to identify high-value segments and create bespoke loyalty tiers or benefits that deepen engagement over time. - Continuously Monitor and Evolve
Leverage sophisticated customer feedback mechanisms, such as sentiment analysis and real-time surveys, to ensure loyalty programs remain relevant. Use iterative design principles to adapt rapidly, ensuring your program evolves alongside shifting market dynamics and consumer preferences.
The Future Demands Connection, Not Transactions
The decline of transactional loyalty programs reflects a broader shift in consumer culture -one that prizes connection over convenience and values over volume. In a saturated marketplace, where every brand promises perks, the ones that endure offer more: a sense of belonging, a shared purpose, and experiences that resonate beyond the checkout line.
This isn’t just a trend; it’s a reckoning. The loyalty of the future won’t be won with points and discounts. It will be earned through trust, empathy, and authenticity. The brands that understand this are already reshaping the rules, proving that, in the end, loyalty isn’t a program. It’s a relationship.
Get regular insights
Keep up to date with the latest insights from our research as well as all our company news in our free monthly newsletter.
Senior Marketing Executive
Sales & Marketing
General Manager PR -Internal Communications & Government Affairs
Vital Strategies
Customer Intelligence Director