The Rise of Second-Hand Shopping and Its Implications for Brand Positioning.

Exchanging pre-owned goods has been a cornerstone of human commerce, from ancient bartering systems to modern marketplaces. The age-old practice has evolved into a booming global second-hand market, prompting brands to rethink their strategies as sustainability and value drive consumer choices. 

Projections indicate the second-hand market will continue its upward trajectory, potentially reaching $350 billion by 2028. 

Understanding the Second-Hand Market

The second-hand market, also known as the resale or pre-owned market, involves the buying and selling previously owned goods. This market spans many products, including clothing, electronics, furniture, and vehicles, offering consumers access to items at prices typically lower than new equivalents. The rise of digital platforms has significantly expanded this market, making it more accessible and organised.

Types of Second-Hand Marketplaces

The proliferation of these diverse platforms has not only made second-hand shopping more accessible but has also contributed to its growing acceptance and popularity among a broad spectrum of consumers.

• Thrift Stores and Charity Shops are physical retail locations where donated goods are sold to support charitable causes. These stores offer a variety of items, from clothing to household goods, at affordable prices.
• Consignment Shops are retailers that sell items on behalf of owners, providing them with a percentage of the sale price once the item is sold. This model is common for higher-end goods, such as designer clothing and accessories.
• Online Marketplaces: Digital platforms where individuals and businesses can list and purchase pre-owned items. Examples include eBay, Poshmark, and Depop, which have become increasingly popular due to their convenience and extensive reach.
• Specialised Second-Hand Platforms: Niche marketplaces focusing on specific product categories, such as electronics or luxury goods. For instance, Back Market specialises in refurbished electronics, providing consumers with vetted, high-quality used devices.

Drivers of the Second-Hand Market Surge

Several key factors propel the rapid expansion of the second-hand market:

• Economic Considerations: Amidst global economic uncertainties and rising living costs, consumers increasingly seek cost-effective alternatives to new products. In the United States, the second-hand apparel market was valued at $43 billion in 2023, reflecting a 10.3% increase from the previous year.
  This growth indicates a significant shift towards more affordable shopping options.
• Sustainability and Environmental Impact: A heightened awareness of environmental issues has led consumers to adopt more sustainable consumption habits. Purchasing second-hand clothing reduces carbon emissions by an average of 25% compared to buying new items.
  This eco-conscious mindset is particularly prevalent among younger generations, with 42% of global consumers aged 18 to 37 willing to purchase second-hand apparel as of 2021.
• Digital Integration and Convenience: The proliferation of online resale platforms has revolutionised the accessibility and convenience of second-hand shopping. In 2023, online resale accounted for 46.5% of the U.S. second-hand market, amounting to $20 billion in sales.
  
  Platforms such as ThredUp, Poshmark, and The RealReal have streamlined the process of buying and selling pre-owned items, attracting a diverse and tech-savvy consumer base.

These factors collectively contribute to the dynamic growth of the second-hand market, reshaping consumer behaviour and retail strategies globally.

Strategic Implications for Brands

The surge in second-hand shopping presents both challenges and opportunities for brands. To navigate this evolving landscape, companies can consider the following strategies:

• Integrate Resale into Business Models
  • Branded Resale Platforms: Establishing in-house resale channels allows brands to maintain control over the customer experience and product authenticity. For instance, Patagonia’s “Worn Wear” program encourages customers to trade in used items for credit, promoting product longevity and sustainability.
    Partnerships with Resale Platforms: Collaborating with established resale marketplaces can expand a brand’s reach. Alexander McQueen’s partnership with Vestiaire Collective enables customers to sell pre-owned items back to the brand in exchange for store credit, fostering a circular economy.
    
• Redefine the Value Proposition of New Products
  • Emphasise Quality and Longevity: Highlighting the durability and timeless design of products can justify the investment in new items.
  • Sustainable Practices: Adopting eco-friendly materials and ethical production methods can appeal to environmentally conscious consumers.
    
• Enhance Customer Engagement
  • Trade-In Incentives: Offering credits or discounts for returning used items can encourage repeat purchases and strengthen brand loyalty.
  • Educational Campaigns: Informing consumers about the environmental benefits of purchasing new, sustainably produced items can influence buying decisions.

Global Perspectives: Eastern vs. Western Second-hand Goods Markets

The second-hand market’s expansion manifests differently across regions, influenced by cultural, economic, and technological factors. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for brands aiming to navigate and capitalise on the global resale economy.

Western Markets

In Western countries, the surge in second-hand shopping is primarily driven by sustainability concerns and economic considerations. Consumers are increasingly eco-conscious, seeking to reduce waste and carbon footprints by purchasing pre-owned goods. The proliferation of digital platforms like ThredUp, Depop, and Vinted has democratised access to second-hand items, making it convenient for consumers to buy and sell used goods. This shift is also influenced by a growing desire for unique, vintage pieces that allow for personal expression.

Asian Markets

In contrast, Asian markets exhibit unique dynamics in the second-hand sector:

• Japan: The Japanese second-hand market has seen significant growth, with the domestic market for used goods nearly doubling 2010 to 2022.
  This expansion is partly due to the popularity of flea market apps like Mercari, which have made buying and selling used items more accessible. Additionally, younger generations, referred to as “reuse natives,” are more inclined toward second-hand shopping, driven by economic factors and a cultural appreciation for high-quality, well-preserved goods. However, this trend has raised concerns about its impact on Japan’s GDP, as second-hand transactions do not contribute to producing new goods.
• China and Korea: A comparative study of second-hand clothing consumption in China and Korea reveals that both countries have experienced growth in this sector, particularly among millennials and Gen Z. In China, platforms like “Xianyu” have become popular. Cultural factors, economic conditions, and technological advancements influence consumer behaviour in these markets, with a notable shift from viewing second-hand shopping as a necessity for low-income households to a trendy, value-driven choice among younger consumers.
  

Implications for Brands

Brands must recognize and adapt to these regional nuances:

• Tailored Strategies: Develop region-specific approaches considering local cultural attitudes toward second-hand goods. For instance, emphasising product longevity and quality in Japan can resonate with consumers who value well-maintained items.
• Platform Partnerships: Collaborate with popular local resale platforms to reach a broader audience. Understanding the preferred platforms in each region allows brands to effectively engage with consumers in those markets.
• Cultural Sensitivity: Acknowledge and respect the cultural factors influencing second-hand shopping behaviours. Incorporating culturally relevant narratives can enhance brand authenticity and appeal.

By aligning strategies with regional characteristics, brands can effectively navigate the global second-hand market, fostering growth and consumer loyalty across diverse markets.

Generational Differences in Second-Hand Shopping

The surge in second-hand shopping is not uniform across all age groups. Understanding these variations is crucial for brands aiming to effectively engage diverse demographics.

Generation Z (Born 1997–2012)

Gen Z exhibits a strong inclination toward second-hand shopping, driven by both economic and environmental considerations:

• Prevalence of Second-Hand Purchases: A significant 83% of Gen Z consumers have either purchased or are interested in purchasing second-hand apparel, surpassing the average for all age groups by 10.7%.
• Economic Motivation: Approximately 64% of Gen Z individuals engage in second-hand shopping primarily to save money.
• Sustainability Concerns: Environmental consciousness plays a pivotal role, with 36% of Gen Z consumers purchasing second-hand goods to reduce their ecological footprint.

Millennials (Born 1981–1996)

Millennials also demonstrate a robust engagement with the second-hand market, influenced by financial prudence and a desire for unique items:

• Regular Participation: Approximately 29.7% of second-hand apparel shoppers in the U.S. are aged between 25 and 34, indicating active involvement in the resale market.
  Financial Considerations: Economic factors are a significant driver, with many Millennials seeking value for money through second-hand purchases.
• Unique Finds: Millennials’ pursuit of distinctive and vintage items motivates them to explore second-hand options, aligning with their preference for personalised and authentic products.

Generation X (Born 1965–1980) and Baby Boomers (Born 1946–1964)

While engagement is comparatively lower among older generations, there is a growing interest in second-hand shopping:

• Participation Rates: Consumers aged 35 to 44 constitute 23.8% of second-hand apparel shoppers, while those aged 45 to 54 and 55 to 64 represent 16.6% and 11.8%, respectively.
• Barriers to Adoption: Older consumers may face challenges such as perceptions of lower quality or concerns about the condition of second-hand goods, which can deter participation.

Implications for Brands

Recognising these generational nuances enables brands to tailor strategies effectively:

• Targeted Marketing: Crafting messages that resonate with each generation’s motivations, such as emphasising sustainability for Gen Z and value for money for Millennials, can enhance engagement.
• Diverse Platform Utilisation: Leveraging platforms favoured by different age groups, including social media channels for younger consumers and more traditional outlets for older demographics, ensures a broader reach.
• Product Assortment and Quality Assurance: Offering a curated selection of high-quality second-hand items can address concerns about product condition, particularly among older consumers, fostering trust and encouraging participation.

By aligning strategies with each generational cohort’s distinct preferences and concerns, brands can effectively navigate the expanding second-hand market and cultivate a loyal, diverse customer base.

Case Study: thredUP’s Strategic Expansion in the Online Second-Hand Apparel Market

Image Credit: Dressember

Founded in 2009, thredUP has emerged as a leading online consignment and thrift store specialising in women’s and children’s apparel. The company’s innovative approach has significantly influenced the second-hand clothing industry, promoting sustainable fashion consumption.

Business Model and Growth

thredUP offers a user-friendly platform where individuals can buy and sell pre-owned clothing. Sellers send in their items using a “Clean Out Kit,” and thredUP manages the entire process, including quality inspection, photography, pricing, and listing. This managed marketplace model ensures a seamless experience for sellers and buyers, contributing to the company’s rapid growth. By 2021, thredUP had processed over 100 million unique second-hand items, underscoring its substantial impact on promoting circular fashion.

Technological Advancements

To support its expanding operations, thredUP has invested in technological infrastructure. In 2017, the company transitioned to Kubernetes for container orchestration, enhancing scalability and deployment efficiency. This shift reduced hardware costs by 56% and decreased deployment times by approximately 50%, enabling faster innovation and improved customer service.

Strategic Partnerships and Market Expansion

Recognising the potential of the resale market, thredUP launched its “Resale-as-a-Service” (RaaS) program, partnering with major retailers like Gap and Walmart. This initiative allows brands to offer second-hand options to their customers, integrating sustainability into their business models and expanding thredUP’s reach. The RaaS program has positioned thredUP as a pivotal player in the broader retail ecosystem, facilitating the adoption of circular fashion practices.

Financial Milestones

thredUP’s innovative strategies have attracted significant investment, with over $130 million in venture capital raised by 2016. This financial backing has supported the company’s technological upgrades, market expansion, and strategic partnerships, solidifying its position as an online second-hand apparel market leader.

thredUP’s success exemplifies how embracing technology, fostering strategic partnerships, and promoting sustainability can drive growth in the second-hand apparel industry. As the market continues to evolve, thredUP’s model offers valuable insights for brands seeking to navigate and capitalise on the burgeoning resale economy.

Final Thoughts

The meteoric rise of the second-hand market is redefining the global retail landscape, driven by consumers’ increasing emphasis on sustainability, affordability, and unique product offerings. This shift is not merely a transient trend but a fundamental change in consumption patterns, compelling brands to reassess and adapt their strategies.

Embracing the resale economy offers brands many benefits, including access to new customer segments, enhanced brand loyalty, and contributions to environmental sustainability. The growing influence of Gen Z consumers, who prioritise ethical consumption and digital engagement, underscores the necessity for brands to innovate continually and align with these evolving values.

Brands that proactively incorporate second-hand offerings into their business models emphasise product durability, and engage authentically with consumers are poised to thrive. The second-hand market is not just an alternative; it is becoming a cornerstone of modern retail strategy, reflecting a broader societal move toward conscious and circular consumption.

As the lines between new and pre-owned continue to blur, the imperative for brands is clear: adapt to the changing tides of consumer behaviour or risk being left behind in a rapidly evolving marketplace.

Get regular insights

Keep up to date with the latest insights from our research as well as all our company news in our free monthly newsletter.

• First Name*
• Last Name*
• Business Email*