Owning Your Audience in a World of Social Media Uncertainty.

The potential ban of TikTok in the United States is more than a policy decision. It’s a reckoning for marketers and content creators who depend on the platform. TikTok’s advertising revenue exceeded $18.5 billion globally in 2024, with approximately $10 billion attributed to the US market alone. For creators, the stakes are even higher; TikTok is a critical income source, contributing an estimated $24.2 billion to the US GDP and supporting over 224,000 jobs. A ban would not only devastate these livelihoods but also redirect billions in ad revenue to competitors like Meta and Alphabet, fundamentally reshaping the digital marketing landscape.

At the core of this disruption is a hard truth: brands and creators do not own their followers. Platforms like TikTok hold the data, dictate access, and can vanish or change their rules overnight. The potential fallout from a ban highlights the need for marketers to rethink their strategies. Diversifying platforms, leveraging market research, and building direct connections with audiences are no longer optional – they’re essential to survival in an unpredictable digital ecosystem.

The Illusion of Ownership

Social media has given brands and creators unprecedented access to audiences – but the power dynamic has always been skewed. Platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube control the data, dictate the algorithms and ultimately decide who sees what. For marketers, this creates an illusion of ownership, masking a fundamental vulnerability: when a platform changes its policies or faces regulatory action, access to that audience can disappear overnight.

TikTok exemplifies the scale of this dependency. With over 121 million monthly active users in the US and 1.6 billion globally, it has become a cornerstone for brands targeting younger demographics.

In 2024, the average US adult spends 58.4 minutes daily on TikTok, up from 27.4 minutes in 2019. This five-year surge in engagement solidifies TikTok as one of the most captivating platforms in the digital landscape. For creators, TikTok offers a lucrative ecosystem, contributing billions in advertising and influencer revenue. However, this reach and revenue exist at the mercy of the platform’s continued operation.

History offers stark lessons on the risks of platform reliance. Vine’s abrupt shutdown in 2017 wiped out entire communities of creators and brands that had invested heavily in its ecosystem. Instagram’s move to a pay-to-play model, prioritising ads over organic reach, pushed many businesses to overhaul their strategies. YouTube’s recurring demonetisation policies have similarly left creators scrambling to replace lost income streams. Most recently, X (formerly Twitter) altered its monetisation model, tying payouts to engagement from Premium users and forcing creators to rethink how they generate revenue.

The lesson is clear: social media platforms are tools, not guarantees. Brands that fail to build independent, direct connections with their audiences risk losing more than visibility – they risk losing their entire foundation for engagement and revenue. As the TikTok ban looms, it’s a timely reminder that the only sustainable strategy is one that puts ownership of audience data back in the hands of brands and creators.

The Market Research Perspective

When platforms falter, market research becomes the ultimate safety net for brands. While social media metrics offer a glimpse into audience behaviour, they’re limited by the platform’s control over data. Market research tools, on the other hand, provide brands with the independence and depth needed to adapt in the face of disruption.

Understanding Audiences Beyond the Platform
Tools like social listening and sentiment analysis allow brands to track consumer behaviour and conversations across multiple channels, not just a single platform. These insights reveal what matters most to audiences – whether it’s sustainability, personalisation, or emerging trends – and help brands craft strategies that resonate even if access to a specific platform disappears. Audience segmentation further refines this understanding, enabling brands to pinpoint which demographics or regions align with their core values and products.

Identifying the Right Platforms
Market research also plays a pivotal role in identifying where brands should invest their resources. Not every platform appeals to every audience. For example, Gen Z users dominate TikTok, but Millennials are more active on Instagram, and professionals gather on LinkedIn. By analysing audience preferences and regional trends, brands can diversify their digital presence strategically, ensuring that no single platform dictates their success.

Pivoting in the Face of Disruption

The 2020 TikTok ban in India exposed the fragility of marketing strategies that depend on a single platform. With over 200 million users in India by 2020, TikTok was a key channel for reaching younger consumers. When the Indian government enforced the ban, citing national security and data privacy concerns, creators and brands were abruptly cut off from a massive audience. However, brands that had invested in understanding their audiences were able to pivot quickly, shifting their focus to platforms like Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts. Bira 91, an Indian FMCG brand, used consumer insights to adapt its campaigns to Instagram Reels, targeting the same demographic. This data-driven strategy allowed the brand to recover a significant portion of its lost engagement, demonstrating the power of audience understanding and the ability to adapt swiftly to new platforms.

Similarly, Vine’s shutdown in 2017 left creators scrambling to maintain their digital presence. Vine had been one of the most influential platforms for short-form video content, but its sudden closure disrupted many creators’ revenue streams. Creators who had taken the time to understand their audiences and the type of content that resonated – whether humour, tutorials, or lifestyle inspiration – could transition smoothly to platforms like YouTube and Instagram.

King Bach, born Andrew Bachelor, is a prominent actor, comedian, and content creator who initially rose to fame with his short, humorous videos on the now-defunct Vine platform. He became one of the top creators on Vine before the platform was shut down in 2017. Unlike many creators who struggled to transition, King Bach quickly adapted his content to YouTube, growing his channel to millions of subscribers. His ability to understand and cater to his audience’s preferences, regardless of the platform, allowed him to maintain relevance and continue his success beyond Vine.

Recent changes to monetisation models on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) have highlighted the ongoing risks of platform dependence. X has shifted its creator payout structure, tying payments to engagement from Premium users rather than ad revenue. This change has forced many creators to rethink how they engage with their audience and generate income. TikTok’s ability to recover quickly after the India ban was possible because brands and creators understood the nuances of their audience, enabling them to adjust their content strategies and move to new platforms without losing significant revenue or engagement.

These examples provide a vital lesson: platforms are volatile, but understanding your audience isn’t. The ability to pivot to new platforms and adjust content to meet shifting audience expectations is not just a reactive tactic but a proactive strategy grounded in solid market research.

The Safety Net for the Future
Market research not only helps brands navigate disruptions but also empowers them to flourish in an unpredictable environment. By consistently analysing consumer behaviour, sentiment, and emerging trends, brands can anticipate changes and adapt proactively.

Building a Platform-Agnostic Strategy

For brands navigating the volatile world of social media, diversification is not just a safeguard – it’s a strategy for sustained growth. Relying on a single platform exposes marketers to the whims of algorithm changes, policy shifts, or outright bans. By adopting a platform-agnostic approach, brands can ensure their message reaches audiences across multiple channels, minimising risk and maximising visibility.

The Case for Diversification
Platforms rise and fall, but audience expectations remain constant. Consumers want engaging, relevant content delivered where they are. Diversifying across multiple platforms allows brands to maintain connections with their audiences, even when one platform’s reach is disrupted. For example, creators who transitioned from Vine to YouTube and Instagram maintained their visibility by adapting their content to the preferences of each platform’s audience. The same principle applies to brands that seek long-term resilience.

Actionable Steps for Marketers

Cross-Promote Content
- Ensure your content isn’t confined to a single platform. Create variations that can live on YouTube Shorts, Instagram Reels, and TikTok simultaneously.
- Leverage cross-promotion to direct followers from one platform to another. For example, a TikTok video can include a call-to-action for a YouTube channel, ensuring audience migration if one platform falters.
Leverage Owned Channels
- Establish and prioritise owned channels like websites, email newsletters, and apps. These channels give you direct access to your audience without relying on third-party algorithms.
- Offer exclusive content, early access, or special discounts to encourage followers to subscribe to your newsletter or download your app. Brands like Glossier have successfully used newsletters to maintain strong connections with their communities outside social media.
Test New Platforms
- Experiment with new platforms to stay ahead of emerging trends. YouTube Shorts, LinkedIn, and niche apps like BeReal offer untapped opportunities to reach specific audiences.
- Monitor the performance of test campaigns to determine where your efforts yield the best results. For example, during TikTok’s early days, brands that embraced the platform reaped massive rewards as it became prominent.

Building a platform-agnostic strategy ensures that no single platform controls your access to your audience. By spreading content across multiple channels, cultivating owned platforms, and staying open to emerging trends, brands can future-proof their marketing efforts.

Owning Your Data

When algorithms dictate visibility and platforms hold the keys to audience access, owning your data is the ultimate form of independence. First-party data – the information you collect directly from your audience – allows brands to build lasting, direct relationships with consumers while insulating themselves from the volatility of social media platforms. This isn’t just a safeguard; it’s a proven driver of higher ROI and long-term success.

The Power of First-Party Data
Unlike third-party data, which is aggregated and often incomplete, first-party data is accurate, actionable, and uniquely tailored to your brand. Studies show that marketing campaigns leveraging first-party data see a 2x–5x higher ROI than those relying on third-party sources. By owning this data, brands can create personalised experiences, predict customer behaviours, and optimise engagement without the constraints of platform algorithms or external disruptions.

Strategies for Building Direct Engagement

Email Campaigns with Value-Driven Content
- Email remains one of the most effective channels for engagement, with an average ROI of $36 for every $1 spent.
- Encourage users to subscribe by offering exclusive content, personalised recommendations, or early access to sales. For example, brands like Sephora use tailored email campaigns based on purchase history to drive repeat business.
Subscription-Based Services
- Build direct, recurring revenue streams through subscription models. Offer exclusive content, VIP experiences, or premium products to subscribers.
- Examples include Patreon for creators or The New York Times’ subscriber-only journalism, both of which successfully monetise audience loyalty.
Community-Building Tools
- Platforms like Discord, Slack, or private forums enable brands to create intimate, engaged communities where they can interact directly with their audience.
- These communities foster loyalty and allow brands to gather insights directly from their most invested users. For instance, fitness brand Peloton uses private Facebook and app-based groups to maintain a strong community connection.

As privacy regulations tighten and third-party cookies phase out, first-party data will only grow in importance. Brands that focus on building these direct connections now will have a significant competitive edge in the future. Owning your data means owning your audience – and in a landscape where platforms come and go, it’s the only way to ensure resilience and relevance for years to come.

Anticipating Audience Migration Patterns

When platforms falter, audiences don’t disappear – they migrate. Market research can help brands predict where their target demographics will go next, ensuring continuity in engagement. For instance, when TikTok was banned in India, many creators and audiences shifted to Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts. Brands that anticipated this migration by monitoring audience preferences and testing campaigns on these platforms were able to adapt seamlessly, maintaining their presence and avoiding revenue loss.

Understanding Emerging Consumer Behaviors
Consumer habits are constantly evolving, driven by technology and cultural shifts. The rise of audio-only platforms like Clubhouse and Spotify Greenroom, as well as private social networks such as Discord, reflects a growing preference for more personalised and intimate digital interactions. Market research enables brands to identify these trends early, ensuring they can tailor their strategies to meet new demands. For example, brands that embraced podcast sponsorships and audio ads capitalised on the surge in audio consumption, creating authentic connections with their audiences.

Identifying Unmet Needs
Market research doesn’t just track existing trends – it uncovers gaps in the market that can guide new marketing initiatives. Predictive analytics and sentiment analysis allow brands to understand what consumers want but can’t yet find. For instance, a food brand analysing health-conscious consumer trends might discover a growing demand for plant-based proteins tailored to regional flavours. Acting on this insight could position the brand as a leader in an untapped category.

Predictive Analytics and Trend Analysis in Action
Predictive analytics transforms historical data into actionable forecasts, giving brands a strategic advantage. Consider how Netflix uses viewer data to anticipate trends in content preferences, ensuring its platform is always stocked with binge-worthy series. Similarly, fashion brands like Zara use trend analysis to predict seasonal demands, enabling them to produce and deliver popular items faster than competitors. These tools help brands remain proactive rather than reactive, turning insights into immediate action.

The Path to Proactive Marketing
Relying solely on past data or platform metrics is no longer enough in a digital ecosystem that changes by the day. Market research provides the foresight needed to anticipate disruptions and stay ahead of the curve. By predicting audience movements, understanding new behaviours, and identifying unmet needs, brands can not only navigate change but also lead it.

For marketers, embracing market research as a forward-looking tool is the difference between being caught off guard and setting the pace. In an unpredictable world, the brands that thrive will be those that see the next trend – or disruption – before it happens.

The Future Belongs to Prepared Marketers

The digital landscape has never been more uncertain. Platforms rise to dominance and fall from favour with increasing speed, leaving brands that depend on them vulnerable. The looming TikTok ban is not an isolated event – it’s a harbinger of the volatility that defines modern marketing. Those who cling to the illusion of platform permanence risk being swept away by the next disruption.

Prepared marketers understand that control is not given; it is taken. They are building direct connections with their audiences, harnessing the power of first-party data, and leveraging insights from market research to anticipate what’s next. They don’t wait for the ground to shift – they shape the terrain themselves.

Get regular insights

Keep up to date with the latest insights from our research as well as all our company news in our free monthly newsletter.