How Retailers are Redefining Loyalty Programs in the Subscription Economy.

Passive loyalty is a thing of the past. Consumers are no longer swayed by points that take years to accumulate or discounts buried in the fine print. What once worked – simple earn-and-burn loyalty programs – now feels outdated when convenience, exclusivity, and instant gratification reign supreme.

Retailers are rewriting the rules. Loyalty is no longer free; it’s a product. From fashion and beauty to tech and travel, brands are introducing paid membership tiers that promise more than just savings. The shift isn’t subtle. Airlines are layering subscription perks onto frequent flyer programs, e-commerce giants are testing premium memberships, and direct-to-consumer brands are betting on exclusivity to drive retention. But as the subscription economy matures, cracks are starting to show.

Consumers are resisting an overload of memberships and scrutinizing whether the cost is justified. Some brands have thrived by offering tangible value, while others have struggled to justify their fees. The challenge isn’t just attracting subscribers – it’s keeping them engaged without alienating price-sensitive shoppers.

Understanding Consumer Expectations in the New Loyalty Landscape

Loyalty is no longer about collecting points; it’s about perceived value. Consumers have become more selective, weighing every subscription against its actual benefits. A decade ago, signing up for a loyalty program was a no-brainer. Today, even well-known brands face scrutiny when asking customers to pay for access.

Subscription fatigue is real. In a crowded market where streaming, food delivery, and retail memberships compete for the same wallet share, consumers are reevaluating what they truly need. A high annual fee isn’t a deal-breaker if the perks outweigh the cost, but brands that fail to deliver meaningful benefits see churn rates climb fast.

Personalization is the new battleground. Generic rewards don’t cut it anymore; shoppers expect loyalty programs tailored to their behavior. The most successful models use data to refine offerings, creating a sense of exclusivity without shutting out budget-conscious consumers. When done right, a well-structured loyalty program shifts the conversation from cost to value, keeping customers invested long after the first purchase.

Types of Loyalty Models in the Subscription Economy

Brands are adopting diverse loyalty models that blend traditional rewards with subscription-based benefits to retain customers. These models cater to varying consumer preferences and spending habits, ensuring a personalized and engaging experience.

Here are the primary types:

Paid Memberships with Exclusive Benefits
- Club Factory VIP (India, China, Southeast Asia): The E-commerce platform Club Factory offers a VIP membership where AI predicts purchasing behavior and provides personalized discounts on frequently bought products. This approach ensures members receive tailored deals, enhancing shopping efficiency and satisfaction.
- Watsons Elite (Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, Philippines): Watsons, a leading health and beauty retailer, offers a paid loyalty program that offers cashback on purchases, VIP in-store services, and early access to product launches. This blend of financial incentives and exclusive experiences creates a sense of privilege among members.
Tiered Loyalty Programs with Subscription Elements
- MATCHESFASHION (UK): This luxury fashion retailer employs a tiered loyalty system where customer spending determines their membership level. Higher tiers unlock benefits such as priority access to new collections, personal shopping services, and exclusive event invitations, encouraging increased spending and brand engagement.
- Trendyol (Turkey): A prominent e-commerce platform, Trendyol offers a tiered loyalty program with regionalized perks, including expedited shipping and special discounts. The program adapts to local market preferences, ensuring relevance and appeal to a diverse customer base.
Hybrid Models: Freemium Loyalty with Paid Upgrades
- Karma (Global): Karma offers a free service that alerts users to price drops on desired products. Members gain access to premium features like cashback on purchases and exclusive deals for a subscription fee, blending cost-free benefits with enhanced paid options.
- Blibli Plus (Indonesia): Blibli, an Indonesian online marketplace, offers a loyalty program with basic membership for free and standard benefits. Subscribers to Blibli Plus receive additional perks such as express delivery and special promotions, catering to casual shoppers and frequent buyers.
Experiential Subscriptions for Community and Access
- Beauty Pie (UK, US): Beauty Pie operates on a membership model where subscribers can access luxury beauty products at near-factory prices. This approach demystifies product markups and offers members significant savings, fostering a community of informed beauty enthusiasts.
- Public Lands (US): Focusing on outdoor gear and experiences, Public Lands offers a subscription that allows members access to exclusive events, workshops, and early product releases. This model emphasizes community building and experiential value over traditional discounts.

Designing Loyalty Programs for a Future-Proof Strategy

Retailers must craft loyalty programs that not only attract customers but also adapt to shifting consumer behaviors and market dynamics. The following strategies offer a blueprint for developing resilient and appealing loyalty initiatives:

Exclusive but Accessible: Pricing Memberships Wisely
- Dynamic Pricing Strategies: Dynamic pricing allows retailers to adjust membership fees based on demand, market trends, and customer segments. This approach ensures memberships remain attractive to a broad audience while maximizing revenue. For instance, offering lower fees during off-peak seasons can entice price-sensitive customers to join.
- Freemium Models: Introducing a free basic tier with optional paid upgrades can lower the barrier to entry, allowing customers to experience core benefits before committing financially. This model has been effective in increasing user acquisition and providing a pathway to upsell premium features.
Hyper-Personalization: Making Memberships Indispensable
- AI-Driven Personalization: Leveraging artificial intelligence to analyze customer data enables the creation of tailored experiences and offers. Personalized recommendations and exclusive deals based on individual preferences can significantly enhance member engagement and satisfaction.
- Behavioral Segmentation: By segmenting members based on purchasing habits and engagement levels, retailers can deliver customized rewards and communications, fostering a deeper connection and increasing loyalty.
Flexibility and Modular Benefits: Adapting to Consumer Preferences
- Customizable Perks: Allowing members to select benefits that align with their interests – such as free shipping, exclusive discounts, or early access to products, can enhance the perceived value of the membership.
- Short-Term and Seasonal Subscriptions: Offering flexible membership durations caters to customers hesitant about long-term commitments, allowing them to engage with the brand on their terms.
Beyond Discounts: Experiential and Social Rewards
- Exclusive Events and Content: Hosting member-only events and workshops or providing access to unique content can create a sense of community and exclusivity, differentiating the program from competitors.
- Community Building Initiatives: Encouraging members to participate in forums, social media groups, or referral programs fosters a sense of belonging and turns loyal customers into brand advocates.
Sustainability and Ethical Perks: Aligning with Values
- Eco-Friendly Incentives: Rewarding sustainable actions like recycling or choosing eco-friendly products appeals to environmentally conscious consumers and strengthens the brand’s commitment to sustainability.
- Charitable Contributions: Allowing members to donate rewards or a portion of their purchases to charitable causes can enhance the program’s appeal to socially responsible customers.

Brands Getting Loyalty Right

Lookiero (Spain, France, UK) – Subscription-based personal styling with loyalty tiers.
Lookiero offers a curated fashion subscription service where customers receive personalized outfit selections. The brand’s loyalty tiers reward frequent subscribers with discounts, early access to limited-edition collections, and styling credits, creating a mix of exclusivity and practical savings.
Asia Miles (Hong Kong) – Multi-partner travel rewards program
Asia Miles, launched by Cathay Pacific, is a travel rewards program that collaborates with multiple airlines and over 800 partners across the dining, retail, and hospitality sectors. Members earn miles through various activities and can redeem them for flights, hotel stays, and lifestyle rewards. This extensive partner network enhances the program’s value proposition, offering flexibility and a wide range of redemption options.
GrabRewards (Southeast Asia) – Multi-service platform with an integrated loyalty program
Grab, a leading super-app in Southeast Asia, integrates its GrabRewards loyalty program across services like ride-hailing, food delivery, and digital payments. Users earn points for each transaction, which can be redeemed for discounts, vouchers, or premium services. The program features tiered memberships – Member, Silver, Gold, and Platinum – offering escalating benefits such as priority bookings and exclusive deals, effectively encouraging increased usage and customer retention.

The Future of Loyalty in the Subscription Economy

As the subscription economy continues to evolve, retailers are increasingly turning to advanced technologies to enhance their loyalty programs. Artificial intelligence and blockchain are at the forefront of this transformation, offering innovative solutions to meet the dynamic expectations of modern consumers.

AI-Powered Personalization

Artificial intelligence enables retailers to analyze vast customer data, facilitating highly personalized experiences. By leveraging AI, brands can predict purchasing behaviors, tailor rewards, and deliver targeted promotions that resonate with individual preferences. For instance, Tesco plans to expand its use of AI to personalize shopper experiences, utilizing data from its Clubcard loyalty scheme to suggest healthier choices and reduce waste.

AI-driven chatbots and virtual assistants enhance customer engagement by providing real-time support and personalized recommendations. These tools not only improve the customer experience but also gather valuable insights that can be used to refine loyalty strategies. Wendy’s, for example, has introduced an AI-based loyalty platform that analyzes customer data to create tailored offers and rewards, thereby strengthening brand loyalty.

Blockchain-Based Loyalty Programs

Blockchain technology offers a decentralized and transparent framework for loyalty programs, addressing common challenges such as fraud, data security, and interoperability. By tokenizing loyalty points, retailers can provide customers with flexible and transferable rewards that can be redeemed across multiple platforms and partners. This approach not only enhances the value proposition for customers but also fosters a sense of community and engagement.

For example, Singapore Airlines’ KrisPay program utilizes blockchain to convert air miles into digital tokens, allowing members to spend them seamlessly with participating merchants.

Similarly, startups like Blackbird are exploring blockchain-based loyalty solutions to connect restaurants with patrons and offer rewards in the form of digital assets.

Integration of AI and Blockchain

The convergence of AI and blockchain technologies holds significant promise for the future of loyalty programs. AI can analyze blockchain-stored data to provide deeper insights into customer behavior, enabling more precise personalization and dynamic reward structures. Conversely, blockchain ensures the security and transparency of the data used by AI systems, fostering trust among consumers.

This integration can lead to the development of smart contracts that automatically adjust loyalty rewards based on real-time customer interactions and predefined criteria. Such systems can enhance efficiency, reduce administrative costs, and provide customers with immediate gratification, strengthening brand loyalty.

Emphasis on Ethical and Sustainable Practices

Modern consumers are increasingly conscious of ethical and environmental issues. Retailers can leverage this awareness by incorporating sustainability and ethical considerations into loyalty programs. For instance, offering rewards for eco-friendly purchases or supporting charitable causes can resonate with socially responsible customers, fostering deeper emotional connections with the brand.

Incorporating transparency through blockchain can further enhance credibility, as customers can verify the ethical sourcing and sustainability claims of products. This approach not only aligns with consumer values but also differentiates the brand in a competitive market.

The Rise of Experiential Rewards

Beyond traditional discounts and points, there is a growing trend toward offering experiential rewards that provide unique value to customers. These can include exclusive access to events, personalized services, or early product releases. Such experiences can create lasting memories and emotional bonds between the customer and the brand.

For example, luxury brands increasingly offer personalized shopping experiences or invitations to exclusive events as part of their loyalty programs, enhancing the perceived value and exclusivity associated with the brand.

Loyalty programs are undergoing a significant transformation. Brands are shifting from traditional point-based systems to subscription-based models, offering exclusive benefits to paying members. This strategy aims to foster deeper customer engagement and secure steady revenue streams.

However, as consumers face an increasing number of subscription options, they are becoming more discerning, leading to potential subscription fatigue. To navigate this challenge, retailers must ensure their loyalty offerings provide genuine value and personalized experiences. Leveraging advanced technologies, such as artificial intelligence, can help tailor these programs to individual preferences, enhancing customer satisfaction and retention.

Addressing the digital divide is crucial; as loyalty programs increasingly rely on apps, individuals without smartphones may feel excluded, missing out on exclusive deals and services. Retailers need to consider inclusive strategies to accommodate all customers.

The future of retail loyalty lies in balancing exclusivity with accessibility, leveraging technology for personalization, and ensuring inclusivity to foster genuine customer loyalty.

Get regular insights

Keep up to date with the latest insights from our research as well as all our company news in our free monthly newsletter.