Decoding Attitudes Toward Finances Across Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore.

In recent years, Singapore has witnessed a notable paradox in financial behaviours. While credit card billings have declined, credit card and other unsecured debts continue to rise. According to recent studies, this trend is particularly pronounced among the younger generations, signalling a shift in their financial attitudes and practices. This juxtaposition of reduced spending alongside increased borrowing poses intriguing questions about the underlying motivations and future implications for financial management among Millennials and Gen Z.

So, how do you decode these financial attitudes thoroughly? 

This phenomenon is particularly interesting when we consider two other spending-related observations that are unique to two specific generations: ‘doom spending,’ or the fatalistic approach to consumption that reflects youth’s pessimistic outlook on their financial future, versus ‘YOLO,’ where a generation of spenders justifies their purchases with a more optimistic /momentous orientation to self-gratification. 

This ‘alphabet soup’ of financial attitudes is further complicated by the ‘FIRE’ movement, where desires to be ‘Financially Independent’ and ‘Retiring Early’ are contrary to spending on whimsical wants.”

Understanding the Financial Landscape in Singapore

The financial landscape in Singapore has undergone significant transformations, especially when observed through the lens of credit card usage and unsecured debt among Millennials and Gen Z. 

Recent data highlights a concerning trend: even as overall credit card billings decline, unsecured debt continues to climb.

A report from The Straits Times points out that total credit card billings fell by 2% last year, yet unsecured debt for the same demographic rose by 5.7%. 

This indicates a deeper issue than mere spending habits; it suggests a shift toward more substantial financial obligations or possibly an increased reliance on credit for essential spending rather than discretionary purchases.

This shift becomes even more pronounced compared to previous generations’ financial behaviours. Historically, credit was used to leverage bigger, often asset-building purchases. However, today’s younger generations increasingly use credit for everyday expenses, highlighting a shift from capital investment to operational spending. The rise in ‘buy now, pay later’ services and their popularity among these age groups supports this trend, offering immediate gratification or necessity fulfilment but at the cost of future financial freedom.

Furthermore, the attitudes toward debt have evolved. 

Previously, debt was often viewed as something to be avoided unless significant assets like homes or cars were purchased. Today, data suggests that Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore are more comfortable with accruing debt, often viewing it as a necessary evil to manage cash flow or as an integral part of modern financial life. This comfort with debt is contrasted with a high level of financial literacy that these generations reportedly possess, which presents a paradox in their financial behaviour patterns.

So, while previous generations may have used credit as a stepping stone to build assets, current trends among Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore show a shift toward using credit for immediate needs and lifestyle sustainability. This evolution in financial behaviour underlines the complexities of modern economic environments and the changing values regarding money, debt, and future planning.

Also, watch my video on The Culture Market-Paradox: Understanding and Serving Singapore’s Diverse Consumer Base.

‘Doom Spending’ vs. ‘YOLO’ – A Generational Shift

‘Doom spending’ refers to the trend where individuals, particularly from Gen Z, spend money with a sense of inevitability or fatalism about the future. Unlike discretionary or luxury spending, doom spending is often motivated by a desire to experience pleasure or satisfaction in the short term, driven by a bleak outlook on long-term prospects.

This trend is becoming prevalent among younger consumers who are facing global crises like climate change, economic instability, and political uncertainty, which are significantly shaping their worldview.

In contrast, we see the YOLO spending trend among millennials.

The Millennials’ ‘YOLO’ spending was characterised by an optimistic, seize-the-day attitude. It emerged from a period of relative economic prosperity and stability, encouraging spending on travel, experiences, and luxury goods as a form of self-expression and living life to the fullest.

Brands that capitalised on this trend, like Airbnb and Grab, promoted experiences over possessions, resonating deeply with Millennials’ desire for adventure and convenience.

Psychological and Cultural Shifts in Financial Habits 

Shift from Hope to Dread

This shift represents more than just a change in spending habits; it indicates a deeper, more pervasive psychological and cultural transformation among younger generations. 

Key aspects include:

• Economic Context: Previous generations, like the Millennials during their formative years, experienced periods of relative economic growth and stability, which fostered a sense of optimism. They adopted a ‘YOLO’ (You Only Live Once) mentality, encouraging spending on experiences and luxuries to capitalise on the perceived stability and opportunities available. In contrast, Gen Z has come of age during times of significant global uncertainty—economic volatility, climate crises, and political unrest- contributing to a more pessimistic outlook.
• Perception of Future Stability: There’s a growing sentiment among Gen Z that the traditional milestones of financial security, such as owning a home or having a stable, lifelong career, are out of reach. This uncertainty fosters a mindset where long-term planning feels less feasible or rewarding, pushing them toward ‘doom spending’—spending driven by a sense of enjoying the present because the future is too uncertain.
• Cultural Reflections: This shift is also reflected in culture and media that resonate with Gen Z, which often portray themes of dystopia, existential threats, and social decay. Such cultural products reflect and reinforce their anxieties, creating a feedback loop that influences personal and financial decisions.

Impact of Social Media

Social media platforms play a significant role in shaping the financial attitudes and behaviours of Gen Z, with specific impacts including:

• Instant Access to Global Crises: Platforms like Twitter and Instagram provide real-time updates on global and local crises, from climate change impacts to economic downturns and social justice issues. This constant stream of information can exacerbate feelings of anxiety and powerlessness, which can lead to spending money as a coping mechanism for immediate emotional relief.
• Comparison and Expectations: Social media also fosters a culture of comparison, where users are continually exposed to curated lifestyles that may seem unattainably perfect. This can lead to increased spending as young people attempt to mimic online lifestyles and experiences, which they perceive as markers of success or happiness.
• Marketing Strategies Targeting Vulnerabilities: Marketers can leverage these platforms to target young consumers with personalised advertising that taps into their fears and aspirations. The omnipresence of such targeted ads can influence spending habits, making it difficult for young individuals to resist impulse buys, especially when these purchases are framed as solutions to their anxieties or ways to boost their social standing.

Understanding these deeper shifts provides critical insight into why younger generations may behave differently from their predecessors regarding financial decisions. It also highlights the complex interplay between individual choices and societal and technological influences.

The FIRE Movement and Its Resonance in Singapore

What is the FIRE Movement?

The FIRE (Financially Independent, Retire Early) movement advocates for extreme savings and investment to allow individuals to retire far earlier than traditional models suggest. 

Its core principles involve:

• High Savings Rates: Adherents typically aim to save and invest 50% to 70% of their income.
• Frugal Living: Reducing everyday expenses to the bare minimum to maximise the amount that can be diverted toward savings.
• Strategic Investments: Investing in stocks, bonds, and other assets to create income streams that support early retirement.
• Income Optimisation: Seeking additional income sources or higher-paying employment to further boost savings rates.

Uptake and Adaptation of FIRE Among Singaporean Youths:

In Singapore, the FIRE movement has seen a unique adaptation. Singaporean youths are increasingly drawn to financial independence, viewing it as a way to escape the high-pressure work environments common in the city-state.

However, the intersection of ‘doom spending’ complicates their financial strategies. While some youths strive for the frugality required by FIRE, others oscillate between strict budgeting and sporadic episodes of doom spending, driven by a desire to find immediate joy amidst uncertain prospects.

This behavioural pattern suggests a hybrid approach to financial independence, where long-term savings goals coexist with short-term indulgences.

Realism and Motivation of Early Retirement Goals

• Challenges: Achieving early retirement in a high-cost city like Singapore poses significant challenges. The high cost of living, coupled with the need for a substantial financial cushion to manage healthcare and housing, makes the strict saving thresholds of FIRE daunting.
• Motivational Aspects: Despite these challenges, the motivation for pursuing early retirement is strong. Many young Singaporeans view financial independence as a form of security against economic volatility and job insecurities, making the sacrifices associated with FIRE seem worthwhile.
• Cultural Influence: Singapore’s strong societal emphasis on financial success and stability motivates youths toward FIRE. It aligns with cultural values that prize foresight, planning, and financial prudence.
• Educational and Support Systems: The rise of financial literacy programs, online forums, and community groups supporting FIRE principles helps sustain motivation and provides the necessary education and peer support to navigate the complexities of such financial planning.

While striving for early retirement through the FIRE movement presents a robust set of challenges in Singapore, it also offers a compelling framework for financial security that resonates with the youth. The movement’s principles counterbalance the uncertainties that fuel doom spending and align with broader cultural and personal aspirations for autonomy and stability in an unpredictable world.

Case Study

DBS Bank – Digital Engagement with Millennials and Gen Z

Image credit: DBS Bank 

Background

DBS Bank, one of Asia’s leading financial institutions, recognised the shift in banking habits among younger generations, who prefer online interactions over traditional branch visits. Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore are tech-savvy consumers who demand convenience, speed, and personalisation in their banking services.

Approach/Strategy 

DBS responded by enhancing its digital banking platform, DBS Digibank, to include features tailored specifically to these demographics. They introduced biometric login methods, an AI-driven financial and investment advisor named “Digibot,” and a user-friendly interface that simplifies the process of financial transactions. DBS also launched a social media campaign to connect with these generations, using platforms like Instagram and TikTok to educate them about financial literacy in a relatable and engaging way.

Outcomes/Results 

The enhancements to DBS Digibank led to a significant increase in user engagement, with a reported rise in young customers who started using DBS for their primary banking needs. The bank also saw improvements in customer satisfaction scores, demonstrating the effectiveness of its digital-first approach. The social media campaigns further reinforced their brand presence among younger consumers, making DBS a popular choice for Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore.

Case Study

Grab – Flexibility and Financial Services for the Gig Economy

Images credit: Seedly

Background 

Grab, a Singapore-based technology company that offers ride-hailing, food delivery, and payment solutions, has a significant user base among Millennials and Gen Z. These generations are heavily involved in the gig economy, either as consumers or service providers.

Approach/Strategy 

To cater to the financial needs of this demographic, Grab expanded its services to include “GrabPay,” a digital wallet that offers a seamless payment solution across its various platforms. They also introduced “GrabInvest,” an investment platform that allows users to invest small, manageable amounts of money directly from their GrabPay balance into various funds, aligning with the FIRE movement principles.

Outcomes/Results 

Grab’s financial services quickly gained traction. “GrabPay” became a popular method for transactions on the Grab platform and across other retail and online stores in Singapore. “GrabInvest” appealed to young investors by offering a flexible and less intimidating entry point into investing, leading to increased participation rates among Millennials and Gen Z. The success of these initiatives has helped reinforce Grab’s position as a fintech innovator while providing young consumers with tools to manage their finances effectively.

Market Research Insights: Complexities and Nuances of Financial Attitudes

Market research insights suggest that while both generations are acutely aware of their financial environments, their responses and strategies differ markedly due to their unique priorities and anxieties. By understanding these nuances, financial institutions can tailor their products and marketing strategies to effectively meet the distinct needs of Millennials and Gen Z. This tailored approach addresses current financial tendencies and anticipates future trends as these generations evolve.

Uncovering Underlying Attitudes and Emotions

• Qualitative Insights: Deep dives into qualitative data from interviews, focus groups, and surveys with Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore reveal complex emotions and attitudes toward money. Common themes include a sense of urgency about the future, concerns over economic stability, and a desire for a balanced life that includes enjoyment now and security later.

• Emotional Drivers: Both generations exhibit a heightened emotional response to financial planning, influenced by global economic uncertainties and societal pressures. Gen Z, in particular, shows prevalent anxiety toward long-term financial commitments and a stronger inclination toward immediate gratification—hence, the rise in ‘doom spending.’

Differences in Financial Priorities and Anxieties

• Millennials: Generally, Millennials are more focused on long-term financial security. They are concerned with building assets, such as purchasing property and retirement savings. This group is also more likely to engage in financial planning services and seek investment advice to secure their future.

• Gen Z: In contrast, Gen Z prioritises flexibility and lifestyle sustainability over asset accumulation. Their financial anxieties are more about maintaining a lifestyle in the face of job insecurity and economic fluctuations, which drives their engagement in flexible financial solutions like gig work and freelance opportunities.

Tailoring Financial Products and Marketing Strategies

For Millennials:

• Product Development: Financial institutions should consider offering products that promote asset building, such as favourable mortgage rates or retirement savings plans with competitive interests.

• Marketing Strategies: Communication should emphasise stability, long-term gains, and financial wellness. Tools like webinars, blogs, and financial planning apps can engage Millennials looking for education and guidance in their financial decisions.

For Gen Z:

• Product Development: Products should cater to flexibility and short-term benefits, such as easy-access savings accounts, credit cards with lifestyle rewards, and investment options with liquidity. Innovative financial solutions like micro-investing platforms or ‘buy now, pay later’ services are particularly appealing

• Marketing Strategies: Marketers reaching Gen Z should heavily leverage digital media, using platforms where they are most active, like Instagram and TikTok. Messaging should focus on financial empowerment and independence, with a tone that resonates with their desire for authenticity and immediate value.

Final Thoughts

The financial behaviours of Millennials and Gen Z in Singapore exhibit a complex interplay of traditional values and modern influences. Millennials are primarily focused on asset building and long-term security. In contrast, Gen Z navigates an uncertain landscape with a strategy that includes immediate enjoyment and cautious planning. The nuances of ‘doom spending’ alongside the aspirational goals of the FIRE movement illustrate a generational pivot that underscores a broader range of financial attitudes and needs.

The diverse financial attitudes of these generations suggest broader implications for the financial sector and policymakers. Financial institutions are directed to innovate to address immediate consumer behaviours and long-term financial health. Products and services must be adaptable, reflecting the fluidity of modern financial environments. On the other hand, policymakers are called to consider these behaviours in their regulatory and fiscal policies to ensure a stable yet flexible economic environment that can support diverse financial needs and aspirations.

Stakeholders across the financial ecosystem must engage with these insights actively and thoughtfully. Financial institutions should consider how they can more effectively meet the evolving needs of younger consumers, not just as a business opportunity but as a part of broader societal support. Marketers and product developers are encouraged to innovate with empathy, understanding that financial products can significantly impact people’s lives. For policymakers, integrating these insights into policy development can help create frameworks that support financial health and stability, fostering an environment where young people can thrive economically.

By embracing these detailed insights into Millennial and Gen Z financial behaviours, stakeholders can better align their strategies with their clientele’s actual needs and desires, paving the way for a more inclusive and adaptable financial landscape in Singapore.